Navigating Today's Hard Market: A Strategic Guide for Independent Insurance Agencies

In the midst of the insurance industry's turbulence, independent agencies face a challenging landscape marked by rising premiums, stricter underwriting standards, and fiercer competition by direct writers. This guide focuses on navigating through these challenges, emphasizing the critical integration of automated communications with the essential human elements of warmth and empathy, and leveraging your relationship with your customers as key strategies for thriving.

Understanding the State of the Market

The state of the market is more than a backdrop; it's a significant force impacting agencies across the board:

  • A striking 70% of agents have felt the hard market's impact on their business operations.
  • Relationships with carriers have grown tense for 69% of agents, adding another layer of complexity.
  • Client retention has become more challenging, with 31% of agencies witnessing client departures due to these harsh conditions.

These statistics aren't just numbers; they're a clear signal that the time for strategic adaptation is now, responding to a landscape in flux.

Adapting with AI and Automated Marketing

Finding a Competitive Edge with Automated Marketing

As the majority of agencies begin to reassess their approach to client retention, the spotlight turns to AI and automated marketing as critical tools for adaptation. While 46% of agencies recognize their benefits, especially in enhancing marketing communications, an alarmingly small fraction—less than 4%—are tapping into AI’s full potential.

Tailoring Communications with AI

AI shines brightest when it personalizes communication. It ensures every message sent out feels individually tailored, enhancing client engagement and solidifying relationships. This isn't just using technology for efficiency; it's about leveraging it to create deeper connections and keep your customers happy.

Leveraging AI for Data Management

Beyond personalized communication, AI plays a crucial role in data management, offering agencies invaluable insights into market trends and client behaviors. These insights empower agencies to make strategic decisions that keep them ahead in a competitive, data-driven market.

The Critical Role of Warmth and Empathy

Even with the most advanced technologies, the essence of the insurance business remains rooted in trust and personal connection. The current market challenges amplify the need for agencies to demonstrate empathy and support, making each client feel understood and valued beyond the transactional level. This human touch is what turns technological interactions into meaningful relationships.

Use Case Example: Client Retention

A great use case of automation comes from client renewals. If a client has a renewal coming up and rates have increased substantially, which they have done in the hard market, there’s two common ways we see this scenario play out:

Scenario 1: Three days before renewal, the client gets their renewal quote with a big rate increase and is highly upset about it.  The client calls your agency demanding an explanation, and shows you a competing quote they got online from a direct carrier asking why you can’t get similar terms for them.  They threaten to leave your agency unless you remarket their account - in three days!  Unfortunately, because most of your book are also getting big increases due to the hard market, you don’t have the time (or staff level) to reach out to the client ahead of their renewal, let alone remarket their account.  The relationship with the client is in jeopardy when you didn’t do anything wrong (it’s not your fault the carrier raised rates by 40%!).  Due to a lack of communication, you now own the rate problem, and it’s possible the client will leave your agency.

Scenario 2: 90 days before the policy’s renewal, you set up an automated yet warm and personalized-sounding message to go out to all clients with that expiration date.  The message goes out explaining the difficult market conditions, an expectation of a rate increase, but your commitment to getting them the best rate possible and to communicate frequently as you work towards renewal. Many times the client will understand the market dynamics, but they’re willing to stick with you because you have communicated to them and have a plan.  You have honored the relationship, and will no doubt show your value as a trusted advisor as you help the client through the hard market.  Congrats! You have successfully achieved having an individual relationship with your client, at scale!

Implementing a Multifaceted Strategy

To effectively implement strategies like this and ensure that you’re wisely navigating the hard market, agencies need a strategy that's as dynamic as the environment they're operating in:

  • Comprehensive Review: It starts with a deep dive into understanding how the market impacts operations and client relationships, setting the stage for a plan with strategic adjustments that involve the client.
  • Embracing Technology: Adopting AI and automation not just as tools for efficiency but as enablers of personalization and strategic insights.
  • Empathy and Engagement: Balancing technological advancements with a commitment to empathy and genuine client engagement, enhancing the value brought to every interaction.
  • Agile Approach: The market won't stay still, and neither should agency strategies. A commitment to ongoing evaluation and adaptation ensures agencies can respond effectively to new challenges and opportunities.


While the hard market presents undeniable challenges, it also offers a canvas for innovation and growth. Agencies that skillfully blend AI-driven efficiencies with a heartfelt approach to client relations are not just surviving; they're poised to thrive. In the end, it's the combination of cutting-edge technology like Bridge’s marketing automation software, with genuine human connections that will define the most successful paths through these turbulent times.


  • Property Casualty 360 “Insurance pros glass half empty or half full
  • Property Casualty 360 “Tech problems continue to vex today’s insurance agents” 
  • Property Casualty 360 “Most insurance agencies grew revenues production in 2023”

Download Whitepaper

Simplify your agency's marketing and communication